“The enemy of our games was always Japan, and the courses were so thorough that after the start of World War II, nothing that happened in the Pacific was strange or unexpected.”
— Admiral Chester W. Nimitz
I recently acquired an antique that engages my interests in history and games. My wife and son wandered into a local antiques ship recently and told me of a discovery they thought I’d like knowing my interests in WWII and games: a gray box containing several segmented trays filled with tiny model ships from the World War II era. My wife and I were in town on Veterans Day, enjoying her day off and taking care of a few errands, so we popped in so I could take a look. I wasn’t quite sure what it was, though I had some ideas; some quick online searches offered a few answers and a research challenge. The price was higher than most anything I buy for myself, but within reason. I am not in the habit of buying pricey antiques, much as I’d like to indulge given my various interests in history. But this seemed too good to pass up. So with her authorization I returned to the shop and purchased what I’d discovered as a set of “Auxiliary Pocket Models” manufactured by South Salem Studios for the U.S. Navy in WWII.
World War II
stands out among the many (too many?) historical periods I enjoy
researching and gaming. While I have a general familiarity with that
conflict, I, like many gamers, have my favorite aspects that I
indulge more than others: North Africa, the Battle of Britain,
clandestine and resistance operations (including OSS and SOE), D-Day,
the Battle of the Atlantic. I own games and have played them and
others (sometimes ones I’ve designed) for many of these campaigns.
The war in the Pacific is one of the more recent areas that engaged
my interest, especially naval operations. I’ve used GHQ’s 1:2400 scale miniature ships for several convention games: the Battle of the
River Plate and South Pacific Patrol. I’ve also read about how the
U.S. Navy has been at the forefront of using wargames for training
and analysis, especially in the inter-war years leading up to WWII.
I’ve written several pieces on the cycle of estimation and action
and how this influenced naval wargaming. So finding a set of
Auxiliary Pocket Models from WWII seemed to emphasize the confluence
of history and gaming that played a role in American naval action.
Battle of the River Plate recently
gamed in 1:2400 scale.
The gray wooden box is 11 3/8ths inches long and 10 1/8th inches wide, with a depth of 2 1/4 inches. Two hook latches keep the hinged box closed and it has no handle. It is heavy for its size, about six pounds. Open it up and one finds two tight-fitting wooden trays stacked on top of a storage area built into the bottom half of the box. Wooden dividers partition each section into smaller compartments, the wood flush with the upper edge of each tray, so when stacked with the lid closed they keep their contents from shifting around into different compartments. Each compartment has a label. And the compartments are filled with tiny waterline models of German and Japanese ships from WWII.
The markings
indicate two scales in the box: one tray for 1:5000 and one tray and
the box base for 1:2000. Each compartment has a label for which ships
belong there: for instance, G CL contains three tiny German light
cruisers. The roster for each Axis power at each scale covers the
basic ship types deployed in WWII: battleships, heavy cruisers,
light cruisers, aircraft carriers, escort carriers, destroyers, even
German torpedo boats, “G TB,” the fast-attack E-boats or
Schnellboote. (Alas, no submarines.) The box also contains
massive sets of tankers, freighters, and transports in both scales,
with a few “unknown” ships. And planes. Many tiny fighters,
medium bombers, and heavy bombers at 1:2000 scale.1:5000 ships and
1:2000 aircraft.
The models are basic: no gun barrels, just simple, almost abstracted superstructures, enough to enable recognition from the surface or air on an appropriately scaled chart. They are probably made from lead. The 1:2000 ships have the two-letter type punch stamped on the fantails, with a starburst or swastika stamped on the bow deck. (The German heavy and light cruiser models have the swastika reversed for some reason.) Sometimes I can discern a stamp of the affiliation and ship type on the underside, which was smoothed flat.
Bow and stern punch stamp details on the German 1:2000 ships.
Alas, I
suspect the set is incomplete. The compartments for the 1:2000 German
battleship and Japanese escort carriers are empty. The one for the
Japanese carriers contains only one model where five or six might fit
in the space. The numbers of each ship type often differ between the
two scales. And I am sure a few planes have been lost over the years
they’re so tiny; I’m not concerned about that since there are so
many of them.Empty compartments
for missing ships.
The box has no official markings on the outside. The interior has the ship affiliation and types printed near the corresponding compartments. On the bottom storage section, which holds the 1:2000 merchant vessels, some spare space contains the only other printing: “MERCHANT FLEET 1:2000. SOUTH SALEM STUDIOS. South Salem New York.” Strangely enough I grew up in Ridgefield, CT, right over the border from South Salem.
Uncovering the Mystery
When I first
saw the set in the antiques store I went home with a lot of questions
about how the models were used and under what circumstances they were
manufactured. Aside from
my uninformed description of the artifact (something like “box of
scale warship models from World War II”) all I had to go on was
“South Salem Studios.”
A quick search online
revealed some information...but nothing terribly
expansive about the Auxiliary Pocket Model Set.1:2000 scale fighter, medium
bomber, and heavy bomber.
My search
brought me to some forums with general musings about such model
ships. I also found some photos and auction listings for larger scale
ships from South Salem Studios. I found the most helpful information
from an article, “Ship Models for the Military” by Fred Dorris,
at a website called “1250 Scale.” South Salem Studios, along with
several other companies, received contracts from the U.S. Navy to
produce scale ship models for recognition training: teaching naval
personnel how to identify friendly and enemy ships from their
outlines and general superstructure configurations, as seen from both
the deck of a ship or the cockpit of a reconnaissance aircraft. Most
of these recognition models came in 1:1200 or 1:1250 scale, with a
few in 1:500 “Teacher Scale.” Sets came in hinged “clam shell”
boxes that opened and stood on their sides for display; individual
ships mounted on wooden bases slotted into place, making a standing
display, though instructors could remove ships from the box for
closer examination.Japanese battleship model comparison:
1:2000 top, 1:5000 bottom.
The photos I found online of sets manufactured by South Salem Studios were all 1:1200 recognition models and sets. Dorris’ article did have one small bit that I immediately realized related to the set I’d found: “They also produced a set of ‘Auxiliary Pocket Models’ of merchant & warships in 1:2000 & 1:5000 scale.” My set had lots of merchant vessels and a good representation of warships (though Dorris makes no mention of aircraft) in both scales. These models, especially those at the 1:5000 scale, seem too small for recognition training, so I can only imagine they were possibly used on charts, to indicate enemy force composition and deployment. But I have no references to validate that assumption.
The Naval History and Heritage Command website has a concise article about WWII era German ship recognition models manufactured by Comet Metal Products Company, a sometime partner of South Salem Studios in fulfilling naval contracts for model ships. The piece doesn’t mention the Auxiliary Pocket Models, but provides some good photographs of the 1:1200 scale recognition models as well as a brief history of the navy’s use of models.
My search turned up some catalog entries at the Mariners’ Museum in Newport News, which we’ve visited in the past and greatly enjoyed. The museum collection includes 44 recognition models in 1:1200 scale from South Salem Studios, mostly American warships and freighters, with one odd Japanese destroyer and entries for a few of the storage boxes. But no models matching the description of the Auxiliary Pocket Models. I casually checked the websites of several relevant museums and institutions to see if their collections held any such models or if they offered useful resources...to no avail. Few had online artifact catalogs to search or online catalogs of library holdings.
I reached out to my contacts on social media for information, too, but received no useful leads, even from some connections in the professional military wargaming community.
Many questions remain. How were such pocket models used in the field? I’m making assumptions they served to illustrate enemy ship dispositions on a map, but that’s just an informed supposition at this point. Does a manifest exist listing the standard box contents, and how much is mine missing? I’d love to find photos of the models in use. Were these pocket model sets widely manufactured and distributed? Who would have used them and been in charge of their safekeeping? I also do not know if a corresponding set exists with U.S. Navy vessels.
I remain eager to hear from anyone with information to further put the “Auxiliary Pocket Models” in the historical context of WWII.
Responsible Intentions
I have work ahead of me as the new custodian of this fascinating treasure from WWII.
I should make an inventory of which ships are included and the number I have in the set. (I should also make sure the ships are in the right locations, as I’ve already discovered a few were stored in the wrong compartments.) The box and trays needs a good cleaning; someone long ago included some folded paper towels to cushion the models (though this prevents the box from closing); they’ve deteriorated so much there’s paper dust in the compartment corners.
I’m not a museum and have no archival training, but using the entry format from the Mariners’ Museum artifacts I’m tempted to catalog the box contents to note the measurements of various pieces along with the numbers and descriptions. Although I’ve included photos in this blog post, I really should try taking better photos of all the models. Part of my frustration researching this artifact came from finding no photographs of the Auxiliary Pocket Models online; I feel a responsibility to share this with others. I have no illusions that my set is the only, extremely rare survivor of its kind, but I feel it’s worth sharing at least so other WWII naval enthusiasts can enjoy it.
Along with a word processing document for notes I’m starting a paper file with relevant information: my bill of sale, a printed copy of the previous owner’s obituary, and a print copy of Dorris’ article (lest the original vanish in the ephemeral internet). I expect I’ll also file any future information I find.
I’m not big
on doing the antique store crawl, but on occasion we stop by the few
in town or visit ones on the road. I’ll definitely keep my eye out
for replacements for the missing ships, notably the 1:2000 German
battleship and any 1:2000 Japanese aircraft carriers or escort
carriers. Not sure if I’ll ever find any, and if I did, if I’d be
willing to pay collectors’ prices for them; but it’s something to
casually pursue in the interest of making the set more complete.Tray with 1:2000 warships.
As a wargamer I’d normally be tempted to use these for some kind of game. But the lack of American ships and the value as a historical artifact makes me hesitate. I’ve considered how I might display these for future enjoyment. Finding a scale map of some Pacific location, perhaps Guadalcanal or The Slot, might make for some interesting photos or a backdrop for a display (though I will naturally be tempted to push the ships around the map with a stick…). Besides, I have plenty of 1:2400 scale WWII ships of my own from GHQ to push around the game table with a stick, if I must.
This find reminds me how fortunate I am. Grateful I have a wife who knows what I like and looks out for me...and gives me permission to spend money on something rare and meaningful. I’m thankful we have the means that this isn’t some unreasonable purchase. I’m glad I have the curiosity to learn more about South Salem Studios and the Auxiliary Pocket Models through online searches, historical institutions, and maybe some military history contacts. I am humbled that I have come into possession of this artifact from another person who, to some degree, recognized its importance. And I hope, when it comes time for me to leave, I find it a new home where others can view and appreciate it...yet another bit of work ahead of me.
“Our treasure lies in the beehive of our knowledge. We are perpetually on the way thither, being by nature winged insects and honey gatherers of the mind.”
— Friedrich Nietzsche